Zest for Learning into the rainforest of teaching and school leadership
Teaching and Learning,Uncategorized
FiveWays of Giving Effective Feedback asActions
NOTE To Teach First TDC2018 Delegates: Slides available here:Teach First Marking
If teachers are going to have a significant impact with the feedback they give, it needs to lead to improved outcomes for students. I am increasingly convinced that feedback needs to be constituted less in terms of a review of what has gone before and more in terms of very specific actions that students should take in order to move forward.
I think that too much effort is wasted in describing the work students produce or in giving generic wishful evaluative feedback along the lines of you need to improve the structure of your paragraphs or try to include more original ideas. Some of the feedback I have seen amounts to little more than telling students to get the answers right or try to produce better work. Instead of running the risk of giving nebulous unactionable feedback, teachers should focus much more on allocating tasks to students that address their learning needs. A student should be able to read or hear their teachers feedback and then do something very specific and concrete that will improve their learning.
To keep this very simple using only words beginning with R, because thats how it started to fall out I think there are broadly five main types of actions that students should be asked to take after their work has been evaluated:
Redraft this piece of work / this paragraph/ this graph. by doing X, by adding Y, by correcting Z
Re-do this piece of work but this time make sure you include X, you measure Y, you state Z correctly.
Redrafting is very powerful provided that the actions are very specific and the scale of the task is manageable for both teacher and student.
This could have been called practise and drill if I wasnt using R words. As any musician will know, the feedback from most instrumental lessons is to practise something specific: some scales, sections of the piece, some finger exercises, a performance, each time paying attention to some very particular skill element for additional fluency. This could work for many subjects including Maths:
Practise your number bonds to 100 with these questions
Practise factorising basic common expressions by doing these questions
In French or English, you could practise writing certain type of sentence: Rehearse your use of future tense/dialogue markers/fronted adverbials/connectives by re-writing these 20 statements adding the appropriate phrase, punctuation or anything that can be done repeatedly.
Note, it is no good asking most students to simply practise doing X. They need to be given specific questions so that they are doing X at right level of difficulty and at the right pace and scale. It is also no good giving them lots of one-off questions. Students need to do lots of the same type of questions to consolidate their understanding before being challenged with a wider variety.
Very simply, this means do these questions. It means, on the basis of what Im seeing, you need more practice answering questions like this. It could mean going back over fundamentals or being given extension questions. Instead of a commentary on what students have done before, teachers simply issue new questions informed by their reading of student work or their test performances. This replaces a focus on retrospective marking with the proactive forward-looking approach of issuing questions or giving students work to do. Quite a big shift in emphasis but one that is likely to have much greater impact.
This is very simply a case of specifying a set of knowledge and asking students to return to the routines of retrieval practice. They may need to re-visit previous learning too but mainly it is a case of self-quizzing repeatedly using a variety of memory techniques to ensure certain ideas, words, equations, facts, details, quotations are learned. Its a very specific form of feedback: You still dont know all of these facts: go and learn them; prepare for a mini-test. That might be more productive as feedback for a history or geography essay than any number of comments on their paragraph structure.
Here, students may have some issues with the scope of their exposure to ideas and are showing the need to show deeper insight, wider references, more imagination. The solution to this could be more reading or more research of a different kind. However the instruction to do some more research could be horribly unproductive or lead down too many blind alleys. Teachers could specify what reading should be done or where exactly students should research but also require them to record their findings.
If you reconstitute all feedback so that any students can receive it and know precisely what they now need to do, in detail, then youve cracked it. This can replace any number of evaluative comments on previous work. Try it.
This is fantastic. Very applicable even to KS2
Thanks Conor. Yes, I think it applies to any context.
Pingback:The five forms of feedback I give to teachers most often teacherhead-January 14, 2018
Pingback:Teacher Tools. Five @teacherhead blogs about teaching for easy sharing. teacherhead-January 21, 2018
Pingback:We know Amy is struggling. The question is what we do about it. teacherhead-February 13, 2018
Pingback:Alphabetical Signposts to Teacher Excellence D Teach innovate reflect-February 17, 2018
Pingback:Get assessment right and reduce workload at the same time. HTRTSummit teacherhead-February 25, 2018
Pingback:ResearchED Blackpool 2018 Mr Lyons Maths-March 24, 2018
Pingback:Alphabetical Signposts To Teacher Excellence F Teach innovate reflect-May 29, 2018
Pingback:Providing Feedback Farnham Heath End School Teaching & Learning Hub-July 26, 2018
Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:
You are commenting using your account.(LogOut/Change)
You are commenting using your Google+ account.(LogOut/Change)
You are commenting using your Twitter account.(LogOut/Change)
You are commenting using your Facebook account.(LogOut/Change)
Notify me of new comments via email.
10 essential discussions to have in any teacherteam.
The Chartered College of Teaching. Whocounts?
Get Into Teaching. The best jobgoing.
Ofsted Inspection is Deeply Flawed says a servinginspector.
The inspirational story of Cardiffs Eastern HighSchool.
Why @researchEd1 is so brilliant. Andnecessary.
Toxic tough talk is still killing us and needs tostop.
Art-Science and other positive tensions that fuel greatteaching.
Ofsted Grades here to stay. Nowwhat?
How can we measure and report progressmeaningfully?
Behaviour Management: A Bill Rogers Top 10
10 essential discussions to have in any teacher team.
School Houses: Joyous eccentricity, tradition, culture… and the rest.
The five forms of feedback I give to teachers most often…
Teaching and Learning Research Summaries: A collection for easy access.
Exploring Barak Rosenshines seminal Principles of Instruction: Why it is THE must-read for all teachers.
Homework: What does the Hattie research actually say?
How can we measure and report progress meaningfully?
Evidence Into Practice: @turnfordblog
Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
How not to implementonWhat is a knowledge-rich curri
Quizlet AmbassadoronExploring Barak Rosenshine
Casebys CasebookonThe Chartered College of Teach
Providing FeedbackonFiveWays of Giving Effective
themannsteronHomework: What does the Hattie
Post was not sent – check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.